With a swift movement of the hand, she cut off the thread. There, it was done now, ready for its death. She looked down fondly on her craft as she held it between her hands. It was a thing, a love-heart shaped thing (at least, supposedly), filled with foam to give it volume. The shape wasn’t perfect and neither was the stitching. But it didn’t have to be.
She put the scissors back in their drawer and found a small kitchen knife. For now that she had finished her creation, it only made sense to butcher it. Unthinkingly, she took her heart-shaped thing and the knife out to the garden, and made a bed for the heart by arranging a few leaves together. The heart rested, seemingly comfortable, unaware of its impending doom, warmed by the sun, lulled by the chirping of birds.
Kneeling in front of the heart, she picked up the knife. Already she felt her throat tighten. She swallowed. Leaning forward ever so slightly, she poked the side of the heart with the tip of the knife, and sat waiting, as if expecting a reaction. When none occurred, she figured she’d have to poke the thing harder.
She swallowed again, trying to push the pain back down, and blinked several times to fight back the tears. She gave one last small, sad smile, and raised the knife above her head. Then, closing her eyes, she forced the knife down, as far down as it could go. When she opened her eyes again, a slit had appeared, and she could make out some of the whitish, cloudy foam.
“I’m so sorry”, she murmured.
She stared at the slit. Her first instinct was to run inside and grab some thread to fix it back together. To make the thing look like the supposedly perfect thing it had looked just a moment ago. To erase the mark of hurt; to erase the mark of the attempt at turning the thing into a complete nothing.
But there was no way she could escape this; it had to be done. And so, she stabbed the heart again. And just as the knife eased its way through the fabric and the foam, so did a memory suddenly hit her conscious mind. And just as the foam oozed out from the larger slit, visions of the past – the beautiful past – filled her up until they flooded her eyes in the form of tears.
She stabbed for all the had beens that she could remember. The laughter, the ecstasy, the excitement; the joyful, meaningful, unforgettable had beens, stabbed until they became joyless, meaningless and forgetabble.
“I am so sorry”, she weeped.
She continued to dig the knife into the heart until she could no longer remember a meaningful had been and her insides felt as twisted and as destroyed as the mess on the bed of leaves. Yet, she had only done half the work. She knew she had to kill every single thing she could, that even a tiny piece of unbroken heart had the potential to keep beating, the savage stubborn thing, and maybe even grow back to its original state. She couldn’t take that risk.
And so, taking a deep breath, she stuck the knife into the thing once more. This was for all the what ifs, all the would bes, the will bes, the maybes, the possibilities. She stabbed all the dreams she had ever dared to dream.
Eventually, the knife fell to the ground from a shaky hand, and the girl curled into a ball to stifle her wailing. The heart-shaped thing, still on its bed of leaves, had turned into little irregular ugly petals of fabric amid a puddle of foam. And she cried and cried, mourning the loss of all that had ever been, and grieving the loss of all that ever could be.